
Since its 1933 opening in Edith Bond Stearns’ barn, the Peterborough Players has helped launch dozens of careers, including film and stage legend James Whittemore, whose final performance was in 2008’s “Our Town.” (Photo courtesy of the Peterborough Players).
TAMWORTH – Francis Cleveland was an accomplished actor in search of steady summer employment when he gathered a group of stage friends one sweltering season, hit the road for his family’s residence in this tiny mountain village, and in the tradition of Judy Garland and Mickey Rooney, declared “Let’s go put on a show!”
The year was 1931. Times were tight and jobs scarce – stage performers were anything but the exception. For Cleveland, who’d earn Broadway renown during his career as the first ever Stage Manager in the Broadway production of “Our Town” and as Elwood P. Dowd in “Harvey,” a fervor for the arts was more than just ingrained, it was as his nephew George puts it today, ‘prenatal.’ As the children of a certain former White House inhabitant and of a lifelong arts patron, Cleveland’s and his sister Alice’s love of entertaining others was an impassioned pursuit.
And so Francis and Alice Cleveland and their band of Broadway friends packed up their props and costumes in pickup trucks, and set about the barns of the North Country and southern Maine, from Plymouth, Tamworth and North Conway to Holderness and Poland Spring, putting on a new show each week and gaining a following that would span generations.
“You would have actors and actresses who over the course of eight weeks would be playing eight different parts in eight different shows,” says George Cleveland. “You could be the footman one week, and the hero the next. It was brutal for the actors, but oh my God, the discipline and experience. And you got to do it in the terminally bucolic village of Tamworth.”
Eighty years later, the Barnstormers, as they’d become known, continue to entertain thousands each summer, still producing eight shows in eight weeks, and remaining among the nation’s oldest and proudest summer stock theatre traditions. Indeed, to enter the old (albeit winterized and renovated) white grainery on Main Street the Barnstormers have called home since 1935, is to step back in time and to, each week, enter a world of their own making. This summer’s production, for instance, of ‘The Ghost Train’ pays spooky homage to the Barnstormers’ first ever show, using actual train gears placed beneath the floor to recreate the rush of a freightliner screaming through.
“We don’t cut corners,” says longtime artistic director Bob Shea. “We remain very involved in every phase of production, creating every prop, every costume, and every set piece and sound effect onsite. It’s kind of like Boeing, except rather than planes coming down the assembly line, we have plays we’re putting together piece by piece.”
And star by star. Over the last eight decades, the Barnstormers, like so many of its counterparts across the state, has seen its fair share of major players in the summertime, whether it was Joseph Cotton and Katharine Hepburn breezing through while touring with ‘Philadelphia Story’ (Hepburn, not knowing she was in the home of late President Grover Cleveland, would take a look at his portrait in the entryway and famously – and unflatteringly – declare its likeness to President Taft!), or the likes of William Christopher (Father Mulcahy on ‘MASH’), Arlene Francis of ‘What’s My Line?’ fame, or General Hospital’s Emily McLaughlin.
It’s all part of a rich summer tradition that NH Cultural Resources Commissioner Van McLeod says only deepens New Hampshire’s legacy as a quiet, rustic retreat for artists to create some of their finest work – from novelists Willa Cather and Louisa May Alcott to Thornton Wilder, ee cummings, and of course, Robert Frost. And for residents and vacationers alike to, in turn, enjoy it first.

Begun as a theatre troupe that traveled in trucks and played barns throughout the region, Tamworth’s Barnstormers this summer celebrates its 80th anniversary, still producing eight shows in eight weeks, including a revival of its first ever show, “The Ghost Train.” (Photo: David Lazar; images courtesy of The Barnstormers).
“New Hampshire has always been a place of refuge for artists not only in the visual or literary sense, but for those who are performers, as well,” McLeod says. “While we’re often quick to think of the White Mountains School of Art or the MacDowell Colony in Peterborough or the Cornish colony, the town halls and opera houses across the state served as their own venue for some of the nation’s most talented performers to practice their craft in the summertime.”
Indeed, to travel from town to town across New Hampshire is to witness a theatre tradition that dates back more than a century to Vaudeville’s earliest days – one where virtually every town hall and Grange hall was built with a balcony and removable floor seating; where towns like Goreham built its opera house right on the train tracks to accommodate performers and visitors; and Rochester’s featured the state’s only hydraulic orchestra section, capable of lifting an entire audience to view a show.
It is to also witness a summer stock culture that remains as vibrant today as it did nearly 90 years ago when Peterborough’s Mariarden Theatre-in-the-Woods seated 600 and featured up-and-comers like Brian Donlevy, Paul Robeson, Cornelia Otis Skinner, and Sugar Hill summer resident Bette Davis. While stages have sporadically sprung up in other states in the decades since, summer stock theatre remains a uniquely New England phenomenon – one which, from its earliest days, capitalized on the region’s status as a cool respite for vacationing city dwellers, and on a deep well of rising and accomplished professional actors anxious for a summer paycheck. In old barns, theatres like the Barnstormers, Whitefield’s Weathervane Theatre, the Peterborough Players and the New London Barn Playhouse found inexpensive (if basic) venues to entertain large audiences, and feature major actors, from “Carousel’s” John Raitt who performed regularly at the Lakes Region Playhouse on Winnipesaukee, to Tony Award winner James Whitmore who began and ended his career with the Peterborough Players.
Today, they remain among 21 summer stock stages across New Hampshire (from the Seacoast to the North Country), entertaining more than 800,000 vacationers and locals last year, and in many ways paying tribute to simpler times when a show was a regular part of one’s summer vacation and the computer generating the special effects was a director’s imagination.
“It’s all about creativity,” says McLeod, who himself founded the Paper Mill Theatre and the North Country Center for the Arts. “It’s easy to be creative when you’ve got a lot of technical gadgetry and million dollar budgets. But in summer stock, where your budgets are certainly anything but, the one criteria by which the audience judges is believability. It really is about telling a story and making it feel real for the people in the seats.”
For nearly as long as the Barnstormers in the White Mountains, the Peterborough Players have been doing just that in the shadow of the Monadnocks, earning a loyal regional following and national recognition as a serious player in summer theatre. Like the Clevelands in Tamworth, Edith Bond Stearns’ decision to launch the Peterborough Players in 1933 came as the child of wealthy summer vacationers who’d fallen in love with the region and were lifelong arts patrons. Stearns’ father had donated the money to build Bond Hall at the MacDowell Colony (where Thornton Wilder famously wrote ‘Our Town’), and when Stearns inherited the family’s 100-plus-acre farm after her mother’s death, it was her friendship with colony co-founder Marian MacDowell that encouraged her not to sell, but to instead open part of the farm as a theatre and proving ground for performers.
The days of a screen covering the entire left side of the theatre to keep bugs out, of horse stalls doubling as dressing rooms, and audience members bringing their own seat cushions and fans on warm summer nights are long gone. In their place is a thoroughly modern, air-conditioned space – though still unabashedly a barn – that has endured because of its connection to the community (locals use the theatre year round, watching the Metropolitan Opera there via satellite in the fall and winter) and ability to attract first-rate performers and directors with quality plays.
“It’s always been an opportunity for performers to gain a tremendous amount of experience in a relatively short amount of time,” says Peterborough Players artistic director Gus Kaikkonen. “Here, they’re able to do the play they’ve always wanted to do and to take part in a quality production outside of New York.”
Over the years it’s a formula that has attracted significant summer talent – actors like William Hurt, Robert Morse, Mary Beth Hurt, NH native and former “NYPD Blue” star Gordon Clapp, and film director Tom Moore – while also serving as a training ground for young actors, actresses and writers. Folks like James Whitmore, a New York native who arrived in Peterborough during the early 1940s in search of experience and summer work. Whitmore would serve in WWII, returning to Peterborough for more roles after being decommissioned. Whitmore was all but penniless in 1947 when he received a Broadway invitation to audition for the role of the Sergeant in “Command Decision.” Stearns, who both believed in Whitmore and in her theatre’s ability to turn out young talent, volunteered to pay for Whitmore’s ticket to New York and to have his roles covered while he was away. Whitmore would win the role and with it a Tony Award, launching a 60-plus year film and stage career that included turns in “Oklahoma,” “Kiss Me, Kate,” and “The Asphalt Jungle” and an Oscar nomination for his performance as Harry Truman in “Give ‘em Hell, Harry!” It was Peterborough, however, that always held Whitmore’s heart. When asked in 2008 at age 86 if he’d consider reprising his own turn as the Stage Manager in “Our Town,” Whitmore reportedly said, “As long as I’m taking sustenance, I’ll be there (in Peterborough).” It was to be his last role.

Just as it has since 1933, the New London Barn Playhouse still rents seat cushions for a nickel, revels in its rusticity, and works as a training ground, teaching performers the ins and outs of both acting and stage production. (Photo: David Lazar; images courtesy of the New London Barn Playhouse).
“You ask us how we’ve been able to last – the support of the town has a great deal to do with it,” says the theatre’s managing director Keith Stevens. “Peterborough is a unique place. It isn’t necessarily a summer destination like other towns with thriving summer theatres that draw tourist traffic. But it is a place with a remarkable amount of culture, and where there is a great interest locally in these kinds of institutions.”
An hour north in the quiet Lakes Region retreat of New London, the Barn Playhouse has been generating significant local interest itself since 1933, helping to cultivate the careers of countless young stars and claiming distinction as the state’s oldest continuously operating summer theatre. Like the Peterborough Players and the Barnstormers, the circa-1820 red barn on Main Street here has evolved quite a bit since its early days when actors would have to exit the theatre itself to reenter on the opposite side of the stage (always interesting, laughs the theatre’s chief historian, when there was a downpour outside and a play was set in the desert); or when a power outage one evening forced the theatre to light the stage with the headlights of a vehicle in the barn’s doorway. Which isn’t to say the Barn Playhouse has donned all the quirks of its age, whether it’s renting out seat cushions for a nickel (the same price as in 1933) to support a long-running scholarship fund, or admonishing patrons using the restroom during a 1989 production of “Singin’ in the Rain” not to flush during the second act because it would cut the water pressure onstage.
All, of course, pale to the quality productions the Barn Playhouse has churned out over the years and to a roster of talent it has developed as one of the stage industry’s top summer training grounds. Indeed, when visiting Mt. Holyoke College professor Josephine Etter Holmes launched the Barn Playhouse, it was with the intent of “establishing a theatre group presenting dramas of stimulating artistic and literary merit.” The result has been a company that each summer gives college students and recent grads a solid grounding in set, sound and costume design, along with the ability to star in shows – from “Fiddler on the Roof” and “Hello Dolly” to this summer’s “Hairspray” – ordinarily reserved for performers twice their ages, if not more.
Among the interns to emerge from the Barn Playhouse over the years have been Laura Linney, Taye Diggs, and Oscar winner Sandy Dennis, alongside writers Tom Fontana (“Homicide” and “St. Elsewhere”) and Steven Schwartz (“Godspell”). One intern from 2007 is starring on Broadway in “A Little Night Music” with Angela Lansbury and Catherine Zeta Jones, while another just finished playing Tony in Broadway’s current revival of “West Side Story”.
“Our mission here is really to nurture young artists,” says Barn Playhouse artistic director Carol Dunne, “to give them a break from commercialism and let them experience theatre as it is supposed to be – created with a tremendous amount of imagination, but not necessarily a lot of money. For a lot of us who’ve been in this business a long time and have worked on and off Broadway, we get more excited here in this little theatre than with the multi-million-dollar productions you’ll find in big cities.”
Judging by the reactions of its audiences, the Barn Playhouse continues to excite them, too, filling seats and sustaining the beliefs of many, like George Cleveland, Van McLeod, Keith Stevens and others that summer stock is a Granite State tradition whose curtain is far from closing. “As you look at history, New Hampshire has always been a place that has fostered artistic development and expression,” McLeod says. “As long as there is the imagination, the inspiration, and the desire from the public, it will continue to be.”
Special thanks to Carl Lindblade, Van McLeod, the Peterborough Players, the Barnstormers, and the New London Barn Playhouse for their generosity and assistance with this story.
Posted under Feature



























































While each has gained an international following, two in particular have been the improbable center of the world at one point in their histories, credited with helping to end one world war and preventing another one from ever starting.














